Diaper Bag Comparison Review – Kate Spade Stevie vs. StorkSak Olivia

Since I own 2 relatively popular diaper bags–the Kate Spade Stevie and the StorkSak Olivia–I wanted to highlight the differences between them.

Here’s what I regularly carry in my diaper bag.

Of course, I carry the absolute necessities like diapers and wipes, but I also carry my own essentials like my wallet, phone, sunglasses, water bottle and tissues.  The bulkiest thing in my diaper bag is my soft carrier–the Baby K’Tan.

Diaper Bag Contents

Diaper Bag Contents

  1. Purell Wipes for sanitizing surfaces like dirty high chairs or diaper changing stations
  2. Nursing Cover
  3. Aden & Anais Burpy Bib in Starlight pattern
  4. StorkSak Changing Pad – comes with the Olivia diaper bag
  5. Extra change of clothes and socks
  6. Baby K’Tan soft carrier
  7. Sophie the Giraffe — my baby’s favorite!
  8. Huggies Wipes and Aquaphor
  9. Huggies Diapers – four size 3 diapers
  10. Furla Wallet
  11. Happy Baby Squeeze Pouch
  12. Bumkins Superbib Dr. Seuss Bib
  13. CamelBak Eddy Water Bottle
  14. Babyganics Sunscreen
  15. My Sunglasses
  16. My iPhone, Keys and pouch with my allergy medicine and a tiny bottle of handcream
  17. Babyganics Hand Sanitizer and pack of tissues
  18. Bumkins Dr. Seuss Wet bag

As you can see, I have a lot of things I like to carry with me!  Here’s what it all looks like packed in each bag.

Exterior of Bags

StorkSak Olivia - Fully Packed

StorkSak Olivia – Exterior

Kate Spade Stevie - Exterior Packed

Kate Spade Stevie – Exterior

The StorkSak Olivia is pretty much bursting at the seams. The outside pockets are difficult to use at this point and I had to squish things down to zip it up.  The Kate Spade Stevie is full but not bursting.  No squishing necessary to zip the bag up.

Interior of Bags

StorkSak Olivia - Interior

StorkSak Olivia – Interior (K’tan packed on top)

StorkSak Olivia - Interior

StorkSak Olivia – Interior (K’tan removed)

Kate Spade Stevie - Interior Packed

Kate Spade Stevie – Interior Packed

The StorkSak requires the K’tan to be packed on top, so anytime I need to get anything from inside the bag, I need to remove the K’tan first before I can access anything else.  This gets a little annoying!  It also gets super full in the center part where Sophie the giraffe is.  I frequently end up unpacking the entire bag just to look for something near the bottom.

As you can see, the Kate Spade packs up everything so much nicer.  I can see everything all at a glance without having to unpack my entire bag!

One thing I will say about the StorkSak is that since there are so many more pockets, everything that has a place in a pocket is easily found.  I always know where the hand sanitizer is, because I put it in one of the end pockets.  Same with my phone because its always in the same exterior pocket.  It’s a little trickier in the Kate Spade bag because there are fewer pockets so more things go in the center.

Overall, I really like both bags.  Both of them carry a lot and I realize I may not need this much stuff with me as my baby grows into toddlerhood!  Hopefully you found this post informative in helping you decide on a bag!    Let me know if there are any questions I can help you answer.

5 Comments on Diaper Bag Comparison Review – Kate Spade Stevie vs. StorkSak Olivia

  1. Michelle
    July 10, 2014 at 12:23 PM (5 years ago)

    It looks like in one of the Kate spade pics you have an attached shoulder strap that would covert the bag into a messenger- did this come with? Where does it attach?

    Reply
    • Stephanie
      July 10, 2014 at 6:34 PM (5 years ago)

      The bag comes with 2 stroller straps. I think that is what you are seeing. You could also buy a strap and attach it to the stroller straps and make it a messenger. I also hook the stroller straps to each other and it is long enough to be a shoulder strap/hanging strap on a changing station.

      Reply
  2. Natalie
    August 11, 2014 at 7:46 PM (5 years ago)

    I just searched for this exact comparison and miraculously, you had reviewed them AND compared them! I was trying to decide between these 2 styles and went with the Kate Spade based on the capacity, look, (and price during a surprise sale!). Thanks so much for your review and the photos!

    Reply
  3. anna
    August 17, 2014 at 3:51 PM (5 years ago)

    which bag is heavier? I’m finding the kate spade to be a bit too heavy for me and was considering the olivia thanks!

    Reply
    • Stephanie
      September 4, 2014 at 10:10 PM (5 years ago)

      Hi Anna,
      The Olivia is lighter. The Storksak Olivia is made out of a lightweight nylon and the particular Kate Spade Stevie that I have is a thick cotton jacquard and leather. Not only that, but due to the larger capacity, the Kate Spade always ends up heavier since I can carry so much more! Both a blessing and a curse I suppose! :) Hope that helps.

      Reply

Leave a Reply